Valentine's Day Coeur à La Crème Recipe

Taylor Murray

January 24, 2024 at 4:09 PM·7 min read

Plate with coeur ala creme - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Valentine's Day is the perfect excuse to try your hand at a fancy dessert you may not have attempted before. While show-stoppers like creme brulée and chocolate souffle get all the fanfare, coeur à la crème is a classic French dessert that has a certain elegance and sophistication that other desserts can't touch. This crustless no-bake cheesecake is perfect in its simplicity: rich and delicious with just a touch of sweetness. And though it requires some time to set, it's quite simple to make.

While the base of mild creamy cheese doesn't vary too much from recipe to recipe, the sauce that accompanies it can change to suit different flavors. Recipe developer Taylor Murray chose a strawberry and blood orange sauce, lightly flavored with vanilla bean. The combination of these two fruits utilizes in-season winter citrus with a Valentine's Day classic: the heart-shaped strawberry. The bright sweet-tart flavors of strawberry and blood orange, as well as their vibrant rosy color, provide a pleasing contrast to the creamy heart itself. Dotted around the heart are segments of fresh, juicy blood orange, which just beg to be nibbled with bites of the creamy coeur à la crème.

Gather The Ingredients For Coeur à La Crème

Ingredients for coeur a la creme - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

The heart of the coeur à la crème is a mixture of various soft cheeses, plus a bit of sugar and cream. For this particular recipe, we are using mascarpone, a sweet Italian cream cheese, and ricotta. To accompany the creme, we're also making a strawberry blood orange sauce using these two fruits, a bit of sugar, and some vanilla bean paste. Vanilla extract can be substituted for the vanilla bean paste in equal amounts, if necessary.

Step 1: Add All The Dairy To A Bowl

Various dairy ingredients and bowl - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Add the mascarpone, ricotta, cream, pinch salt, and 1 tablespoon sugar to a large bowl.

Step 2: Whisk The Cheeses

Bowl of whipped cheeses - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Whisk until smooth.

Step 3: Prepare The Molds

Sheet tray with heart molds - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Set 2 large heart-shaped cookie cutters over a wire rack on a rimmed baking sheet.

Step 4: Line The Molds With Cheesecloth

Heart molds lined with cloth - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Line each cookie cutter with cheesecloth. Alternatively, use a coeur à la crème mold lined with cheesecloth.

Step 5: Add The Cheese Mixture

Cheese added to heart molds - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Spoon the cheese mixture into the cookie cutters and let it sit overnight in the refrigerator.

Step 6: Start The Strawberry Sauce

Strawberry and sugar in pan - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Meanwhile, in a small saucepan, combine the strawberries, blood orange juice, vanilla bean paste, and remaining sugar. Add about ⅔ of the blood orange segments.

Step 7: Simmer The Sauce

Simmered strawberry fruit mixture - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Bring the mixture to a boil then simmer until it's syrupy and tiny bubbles appear in the liquid. Let it cool slightly.

Step 8: Blend The Fruit Sauce

Blender bowl with strawberry sauce - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Transfer the mixture to a blender and blend until smooth.

Step 9: Strain The Sauce

Small strainer over small bowl - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Strain through a fine-meshed sieve. Set aside.

Step 10: Plate The Cheese Hearts

Small cheese heart on plate - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

When ready to serve, transfer the cheese hearts to small plates.

Step 11: Smooth The Hearts

Two plates with cheese hearts - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Spread the hearts lightly to smooth the edges if needed.

Step 12: Add The Sauce

Two plates with strawberry sauce - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Spoon the strawberry sauce around the hearts.

Step 13: Add The Blood Orange

Scatter the remaining blood orange segments around the hearts. Serve immediately.

What Kinds Of Cheeses Can You Use For A Coeur à La Crème?

Bowls of soft cheeses - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

Coeur à la crème traditionally employs a variety of cheeses as its base. The choice of cheese largely depends on the desired consistency and flavor profile of the Coeur à la crème. The most common choice is cream cheese, which is valued for its smooth texture and mild flavor and often serves as the primary cheese component. For a more authentic and nuanced flavor, French Neufchâtel can be used: It's similar to cream cheese but offers a slightly grainier texture and a more pronounced taste. For a surprising twist, you could opt for a more unconventional cheese like goat cheese. This tart and tangy cheese would add a pronounced but delightful flavor to this dessert.

Additionally, some recipes might call for a combination of these cheeses, or, as in this recipe, incorporate ricotta, which adds a light, slightly grainy texture, and a subtly sweet flavor. Though this recipe simply calls for heavy cream, you might find recipes that add a tangier element with the addition of sour cream or crème fraîche.

Do You Need A Special Mold To Make This Recipe?

Cheeses pressed into heart molds - Taylor Murray/Tasting Table

The classic coeur à la crème mold is a distinctive piece of kitchenware specially designed for making this traditional French dessert. It is characteristically heart-shaped, in keeping with the romantic theme of the dish (the name "coeur à la crème" literally means "heart of cream" in French). The mold is usually made of porcelain or plastic and features a series of small holes at the bottom. These holes are crucial for the dessert's preparation, as they allow whey and excess liquid to drain from the cheese mixture, resulting in a firmer, more concentrated dessert.

If you don't have one of these molds, there are a variety of workarounds. As in this recipe, you can use a heart-shaped cookie cutter set over a wire rack and lined with cheesecloth. If you don't have any heart-shaped cutters, any shape will do (as long as you don't mind compromising the romantic theme). You can also use a fine mesh sieve, in which case you'll end up with a more dome-shaped result.